National

Opinion: The long queue that nobody cares to ask about

Every child in town learns an unwritten rule without being taught, a long queue must mean something good is being given out. Nobody walks to the back of a line and asks what is on offer. They simply join, and the longer the line, the surer they feel. There was a time in the early 2000S when most of us in Zimbabwe would queue outside a bank, a clinic or a fuel station, and only worked out what the line was for when we reached the front.

Now picture a different queue. It is not for bread or fuel. At the front stands a smiling person waving a bundle of notes, telling anyone who passes that they put in $100 last month and got $130 back. The notes are real. You can see them. Behind that person, hundreds of people shuffle forward, each one reassured by the shoulders in front of them.

That queue has a name. It is called a pyramid scheme, and in Zimbabwe it is growing again, travelling from WhatsApp groups to mobile apps to offices on our busiest streets. With the festive season creeping closer, it is getting longer by the day.

Salt from the neighbours

To understand the trick, forget finance for a moment and think of a woman who borrows a cup of salt from one neighbour to pay back another. When the second neighbour comes asking, she borrows sugar from a third to settle with the first. For a while the whole street admires her. Everyone who lent her something gets it back, so everyone says she is wonderful with household affairs. But she has never bought a single grain. The day one neighbour says “no more”, the street discovers the cupboard was empty all along.

On this topic

That is a Ponzi scheme, old investors are paid with new investors’ money, and no real business sits in the middle. A pyramid scheme adds a twist, because to earn you must bring in your own neighbours. Either way, the early payouts are bait. A fisherman scatters a few crumbs to bring the fish to the surface before he drops the net. Those first few people really do get paid, and they become the loudest cheerleaders in the village, because for them it is true. Every scheme keeps a few of these living advertisements on display.

Bulawayo has watched this film before

Older Bulawayo residents will tell you the city has been here before. In the 1990s, many residents lost their homes and other property to a scheme that promised double returns in two days. Then came 2012 and 2013.

Geozing Pawnbrokers, led by George Zingane, invited people to deposit their money and promised 30 percent interest every month. At the time, banks were paying anything from nothing to four percent a year. Do the math – 30 percent a month is 360 percent a year, before you even count compounding. It is like being told that a bus ticket to Harare costs less than a packet of sweets. The offer defied arithmetic, but the queue’s length and the quality of the people in it drowned it out. Reports said the clients included senior police and prison officers, army officials and church leaders. A burial society and a small charity were also on the investors’ list. Some people sold their cars and houses to get in.

When the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) began looking into the operation, the money stopped flowing. A register of confirmed investors listed more than 2,500 people who had lost over $4 million between them, and liquidators later spoke of close to 4,000 names.

What followed after the collapse of the scheme was a long and exhausting legal battle. Liquidators were appointed. A commission of inquiry was set up to track down assets that had not been declared. Hundreds of creditors packed the Bulawayo Amphitheatre, demanding to see Mr Zingane face to face. Cars were auctioned to settle a debt to at least one client.

Here is the part that still stings. Mr Zingane publicly insisted that the reports of fraud were untrue, and the State’s fraud case against him and his company was eventually withdrawn because it was weak. He was convicted under the Banking Act and fined $4,000 for the company and $3,000 for himself, and he was later reported to have defaulted on even that. Against losses in the millions, those figures tell their own story. I am not here to put on trial a man the courts did not convict of fraud. I am here to point out how that gap must have felt to people who had sold their houses.

Before the Geozing dust had settled, a second Bulawayo scheme, Perfect Shot Investments, began to crumble. Its director, Kelvin Mazhandu, was a young man of 24. Prosecutors said the company invited deposits and promised returns of 30 to 35 percent a month.

Most of its investors were civil servants, teachers, soldiers and police officers, exactly the people whose payslips had stopped stretching to the end of the month.

When it collapsed in May 2013, angry investors besieged its offices for days, hearing assurances that everyone would be paid by a set date. The date came and went.

Then came the turn that investors in these schemes dread most: the face on the posters disappeared. Mr Mazhandu allegedly fled to South Africa, was arrested on his return and charged with fraud, and later went on the run again after skipping bail. He was arrested in December 2014 after about a month in hiding. Prosecutors said investors had deposited as much as $1 million, although earlier court reports spoke of more than $160,000.

In February 2015 the court acquitted him and his company, ruling that while the company had failed to deliver the returns it promised, there was no evidence that it had misrepresented anything else.

One case withdrawn, one acquittal. An acquittal tells you what the State could prove. It cannot put money back in a teacher’s pocket. A Bulawayo lawyer warned at the time that because investors had signed with companies and not with individuals, getting their money back would be an uphill climb, and many never would.

Same film, new screen

Ten years later the pawnshop counter had been replaced by a phone screen. E-Creator, registered as a company in February 2023, asked people to do small online “jobs”, such as clicking buttons to boost product orders and reviews. To start as a VIP 1 member, you paid about $15 and were promised $50 back. To move up the levels, you had to bring in other people. Thousands joined.

In July 2023, a notice appeared on its website saying it had stopped operating and that its founder had fled with the investors’ savings. Reports said some people had even dipped into their employers’ money, hoping to put it back with profit before anyone noticed. The Chinese national alleged to be behind it, Zhao Jiaotong, was arrested. In the trial he is accused of defrauding more than 670 investors of over $364,000, although early reports put the losses above $1 million, and he denies wrongdoing. The case was still before the Harare courts earlier this year, and the people who lost money are still waiting.

The same itch is now being scratched by games. Betting games like Aviator and JetX, and gacha-style games where you pay for a spin and hope a rare prize drops, work like a slot machine in your pocket: a small payment, a tap of the screen, a few heartbeats of suspense. Local reports describe such games as both lifeline and trap for young Zimbabweans, and one economist put it fairly: there is nothing evil in a game, the danger comes when it becomes a substitute for a job.

In 2021, police said at least 10,000 Zimbabweans had lost around $30 million to pyramid schemes in a single year, and some families had sold houses and vehicles to join in. The names change, the faces change, the screens change. The queue does not.

Why the queue is growing

Let me be plain: this queue is an economic indicator. When people join it in such numbers, they are telling us something about their lives that the headline figures do not.

Salaries have stood still while the cost of living has not. A pay packet that stays the same while prices climb is like a blanket that shrinks every winter. You can pull it up to your chin, but now your feet are out in the cold. At some point you stop adjusting it and start looking for a bigger blanket.

Young people were handed a map: study hard, get a job, build a life. Many arrived to find the road closed. With no road, they take whatever footpath anyone points them to, and a get-rich scheme is always pointing.

Those who tried to build businesses are not spared. Many entrepreneurs argue that rising operating costs, taxes and the burden of regulation are squeezing small firms, while bank loans are expensive or out of reach. When the front door of the bank is shut, the window of a stranger starts to look welcoming.

Then comes December. It is the month when every bill arrives at once: groceries, new clothes for the children, the trip home to the village, and school fees waiting in January. A scheme that promises to turn November’s $100 into December’s $130 knocks on the door at exactly the hour a person is most anxious. Scammers know our calendar better than the banks do.

What the brain is doing

Here is the part we rarely say out loud: the people who join are not stupid. Think about what these schemes really sell. It is not an investment. It is hope in a 30-day packet.

Hope is what makes a farmer plant when the rains are late. The scheme borrows that same instinct and points it in the wrong direction. Add a few tricks of the mind that psychologists have documented for years.

First, we copy the crowd. If a cousin, a pastor or a workmate has joined, we hand our judgment over to them. That is the queue rule again.

Second, we are hooked by a “maybe” more than a “definitely”. An uncertain reward excites the brain more than a guaranteed one, which is why a slot machine or a gacha spin keeps people pulling long after they should have stopped. Small early payouts feed this, because the occasional win keeps hope alive through many losses.

Third, we hate wasting what we have already spent. A man who has pushed a broken-down car for three kilometres is the last person to abandon it. In a scheme, the same logic whispers: you have put in $200, so put in another $100 to rescue it. This is why so many investors reinvest instead of withdrawing, and why the collapse hits so hard.

Fourth, the clock. Slots are filling, the bonus ends on Friday, the window is closing. Urgency is manufactured so you will not have time to ask the awkward question.

And finally, there is the dream. Someone once told me that ours is a generation that believes it can simply download money from the internet, the way we download a song or a film. Social media shows us a steady parade of people flaunting wealth with no visible job. The screen makes money look like a file waiting for the right link. But money is not a file. It is somebody’s work, somebody’s risk and somebody’s time.

The elephant and the spear

Ask a victim why they went back after being burnt, and you may hear an old saying: Let the young man in his poverty go out and hunt an elephant. If he kills the elephant, his poverty ends. If the elephant kills him, his poverty ends.

There is grim wisdom in it. When you feel you have nothing left to lose, risk starts to look like courage. But look again at the people in the Geozing and Perfect Shot queues. They were not men with nothing. They were teachers, soldiers, police officers, church leaders and burial societies, people with salaries and roofs, some of whom sold their cars and houses. The saying promises that in the worst case, poverty ends. It does not tell you that in a pyramid the worst case is a deeper poverty, with debts, a sold home and a shamed face. And the elephant in these schemes is not a wild animal at all. It is a trap, set by someone hunting with everybody else’s spears.

Not only our problem, and not about race

We are not alone. Pyramid and Ponzi schemes are popular in Canada and the United States too, and they are especially visible in some African and Black communities there. Let me be careful: this is not a race problem, and it does not mean Africans are more gullible. It is a trust problem. These schemes travel through the places where people already trust one another: churches, burial societies, WhatsApp groups, mukando clubs and migrant networks. Honest savings clubs have existed in our communities for generations, so the scheme borrows their language and their credibility. When mainstream finance feels closed or unfriendly, as it often does to newcomers with thin credit histories, a friendly face from your own church pew walks in through the front door. The few outsiders who move in those circles get pulled in by the same friendly hands.

The same con wears a suit elsewhere. Bernie Madoff ran the largest Ponzi scheme in history, worth tens of billions of dollars, by building trust inside his own social circles. Trust is the real currency. The pyramids just spend it.

Before you join the next queue

So what do we do? Walk to the front of the queue and ask the person holding the notes three questions. Where does the money actually come from? Who licenses and regulates this business, and can I check? And what happens if nobody new joins tomorrow? If the honest answer to the last question is “it falls apart”, you are looking at a pyramid. A promise of 30 percent a month is not an investment. It is a dare.

But we cannot lecture hungry people out of hope. The Reserve Bank and the police have issued warnings again and again, and the queue has grown anyway. What will shrink it is not scolding but options: jobs that pay, cheaper and safer ways for small businesses to borrow, savings products that ordinary people can trust, and regulators and prosecutors who move before the collapse rather than after it. Until then the queue will keep growing, and somebody will keep standing at the front, waving the notes.

The poor man deserves a better hunt than that.


Staff Reporter Avatar
Share this story with your friends

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The history is dying with its witnesses. Help us to record and preserve it.

Become a Member today


Your daily round-up of stories from Matabeleland and beyond, straight to your inbox every afternoon

Related news

  • Opinion: Pfungwa dzedu dzinonetera papi? Zimbabwe must learn to build tomorrow’s economy
    19th November 2026
  • Patriotic Alliance calls for impartial ConCourt hearing as it backs CAA3 challengers 
    18th November 2026
  • ZHRC calls for reduction of passport fees
    18th November 2026

Russia-Ukraine War:

A CITE Special Investigation

What happened to the Zimabweans recruited to fight?

Latest from CITE