The Supreme Court has overturned the murder conviction of a Bulawayo man who was serving a 23-year prison sentence for his alleged involvement in the killing of Nothoyethu Sibanda during a fight outside Egumeni Sports Bar at Makoni Shopping Centre in Pumula.
Mpumuzi Dube was convicted alongside Nkanyiso Ndlovu and Ndumiso Sibanda by the Bulawayo High Court in February this year following a fatal altercation on March 30, 2024.
However, the Supreme Court, sitting in Bulawayo on Wednesday, upheld Dube’s appeal, quashed his murder conviction and substituted it with a verdict of not guilty, effectively setting aside his sentence.
The appeal centred on whether the State had proved beyond reasonable doubt that Dube participated in the fatal assault and shared a common intention with his co-accused to kill Sibanda.
On this topic
In his heads of argument, Dube’s lawyer, Simbarashe Madzivire of Mashayamombe Co & Attorneys, argued that the High Court had erred in convicting his client despite insufficient evidence linking him to the killing.
“The appeal turns on a simple complaint: the court a quo erred and misdirected itself on both the law and the facts when it convicted the appellant of murder yet the State had failed to discharge the onus,” Madzivire submitted.
He argued that three State witnesses, Walter Mutungwa, Muziwakhe Ncube and investigating officer Simangaliso Mupedzapasi, had not placed Dube at the scene of the fatal assault.
Madzivire also submitted that CCTV footage reviewed during investigations did not show Dube near the scene where Sibanda was killed and that no incriminating evidence had been recovered from him.
He further challenged the credibility of the State’s key witness, Sithulisile Ncube, who claimed to have witnessed the assault.
According to Madzivire, Ncube had admitted during the trial that she was arrested in connection with the murder before recording a statement with police and was detained for two days.
“She made damning admissions that she made a statement at the police station out of fear to serve herself from the misery of being detained,” he submitted.
Madzivire also disputed claims that Dube had struck Sibanda with a stone, arguing that the post-mortem report did not record head injuries consistent with such an assault.
The State opposed the appeal, maintaining that Dube had participated in the attack and was liable for murder under the doctrine of common purpose.
Representing the State, Kudakwashe Jaravaza argued that Dube had been at Egumeni Sports Bar with his co-accused before the incident and had taken part in the events leading to Sibanda’s death.
“The only issue that needs interrogation in this case is the role of the Appellant in the events that led to the demise of the deceased,” Jaravaza submitted.
The State further argued that Dube’s conduct before, during and after the assault demonstrated that he had associated himself with the other accused in committing the offence.
Jaravaza relied on Ncube’s testimony that she had seen Dube strike Sibanda with a stone, causing him to fall.
“The Respondent finally submits that the State did prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt. No evidence can ever go beyond the testimonies of these witnesses who appeared and testified before the court a quo,” the State’s heads of argument read.
In convicting the three men, the High Court had found that they acted in concert, blocking Sibanda and his companions from leaving the premises before attacking them.
However, the Supreme Court allowed Dube’s appeal by consent, quashed his conviction and substituted it with a verdict of not guilty.
The appeal was heard by Judge President Justice Charles Hungwe, Justice Mary Zimba-Dube and Justice Alfas Chitakunye.


Leave a Reply