Promises vs. Progress: Zimbabweans React to Mnangagwa’s Independence Day Speech
As Zimbabwe marked 44 years of Independence yesterday, President Emmerson Mnangagwa delivered a speech to rally the nation behind his vision for the countryโs future.
However, the speech was met with mixed reactions, with some citizens hailing it while others dismissed it as empty rhetoric.
The question lingering for many Zimbabweans is whether the government can fulfill its promises of economic development and political stability.
In his address, President Mnangagwa highlighted the countryโs bright economic outlook citing a GDP exceeding $47 billion.
He highlighted the work done during theย El Ninoโinduced challenges and underscored the strides made in infrastructure development,ย prioritising civilย servantsโ welfare, and empowering women and communities through funding small and medium enterprises among other issues.ย
However, discussing the speech on This Morning on Asakhe, a CITE daily current affairs programme on X, participants were not convinced.
Participants, such as Mzansi Kandaba, criticised the governmentโs focus on road construction in Mashonaland, neglecting development in Matabeleland.
โThe reality is that in Matabeleland we haven’t experienced any independence since the inception of independence, we know what happened in Matabeleland. The government has moved to another stage of Gukurahundi of depriving Matabeleland of resources, the roads are not developed in Matabeleland.โ
โAll the roads which are being developed and the development which he spoken about is happening in Mashonaland, currently we have a problem with the Nkayi road and nobody is saying anything about that. We have a problem also with Beitbridge- Bulawayo Road, we only ask two things from the government that they can fix those two roads,โ he said.
On road rehabilitation, the government is in the process of rehabilitating the Bulawayo-Victoria Falls highway.
Another speaker,ย Namaphahlaย blamed the ruling party, ZANUโPF, for giving citizens small handouts so that theyย remainย hopeful.ย
โThe things that are being said are like the music in our ears, no one is going to be left behind, no one is going to get hungry,โ she said.
She said while President Mnangagwa highlighted some positives in his speech, those are, however, overshadowed by ZANU-PFโs incompetence.
Another speaker, Njabulo remarked that the Presidentโs speech echoed promises made since 2018, questioning the contrasting narrative of economic growth amid challenges like drought.
โWhen you listen to the speech, he spoke about issues to do with our GDP,ย he said we are now sitting at 47 billion and he spoke about how the mining sector is doing well in terms of both the local players andย externalย players that haveย comeย in andย invested in theย mining sector. He spoke about the past year saying it was a good year in terms of production. He went on to speak about the El Nino induced drought, one of the things that really amazesย me aboutย the whole speechย is the factย that weย are doing well and doing bad at the sameย time inย the very same speech.โย
โWe are doing well in terms of us as a country that we have grown in our GDP, we are doing well inย terms of the mining sector if the mining sector is doing well it means we have done well in terms of collecting taxesย and revenues, it means as a country we should be able to take care of ourselves in terms of feeding our population especially when we have hit a brick like thisย one where we know we have drought which has come through,โ he said.ย
However, Khumbulani Maphosa argued that there is a need to redefine independence.
โWe need to define the term independence, freedom is not about the elimination of a settler colonial regime, it is measured by the indicators of the freedoms that the ordinary citizens are getting and as an ordinary citizen I don’t get those freedoms, things are changed without the consultation of the people,โ said Maphosa.
However,ย aย contrastingย view highlighted progress under President Mnangagwaโs leadership, citing verifiable economic growth andย internationalย validation through the International Monetary Fund (IMF). ย
โThese are numbers that are not cooked up, all economist across the World verifies them, Zimbabwe is on a monitored program by the IMF so Zimbabwe is not lying when they are saying the economy has grown and there is a lot of significant progress that has been happening under Presidentย Mnangagwaย because he has not been in power for 44 years, he has only been in power since 2017 up until now.ย Those peopleย that come up and ignorantly say that Mnangagwa has been given the same speech for 44 years,ย I think theyย naturally hate Zimbabwe,โ he said.ย